History |
Wars & Campaigns |
►Boer
War
►First
World War
►►Western
Front
►►►Trench
Warfare: 1914-1916
►►►Allied
Offensive: 1916
►►►Allied
Offensives: 1917
►►►German
Offensive: 1918
►►►Advance
to Victory: 1918
►►Siberia
►Second
World War
►►War
Against Japan
►►North
Africa
►►Italian
Campaign
►►►Sicily
►►►Southern
Italy
►►►The
Sangro and Moro
►►►Battles
of the FSSF
►►►Cassino
►►►Liri
Valley
►►►Advance
to Florence
►►►Gothic
Line
►►►Winter
Lines
►►North-West
Europe
►►►Normandy
►►►Southern
France
►►►Channel
Ports
►►►Scheldt
►►►Nijmegen
Salient
►►►Rhineland
►►►Final
Phase
►Korean
War
►Cold
War
►Gulf
War |
Operations |
|
Battle Honours |
Boer War
First World War
Western Front
Trench Warfare: 1914-1916
Allied Offensive: 1916
►Somme, 1916 |
1
Jul-18 Nov 16 |
►Albert |
.1-13
Jul 16 |
►Bazentin |
.14-17
Jul 16 |
►Pozieres |
.23
Jul-3 Sep 16 |
►Guillemont |
.3-6
Sep 16 |
►Ginchy |
.9
Sep 16 |
►Flers-Courcelette |
15-22
Sep 16 |
►Thiepval |
26-29
Sep 16 |
►Le Transloy |
.
1-18 Oct 16 |
Allied
Offensives: 1917
►Arras 1917 |
8
Apr-4 May 17 |
►Vimy, 1917 |
.9-14
Apr 17 |
►Arleux |
28-29 Apr 17 |
►Scarpe, 1917 |
.3-4
May17 |
►Hill 70 |
.15-25
Aug 17 |
►Messines, 1917 |
.7-14
Jun 17 |
►Ypres, 1917 |
..31
Jul-10 Nov 17 |
►Pilckem |
31
Jul-2 Aug 17 |
►Langemarck, 1917 |
.16-18
Aug 17 |
►Menin Road |
.20-25
Sep 17 |
►Polygon Wood |
26
Sep-3 Oct 17 |
►Broodseinde |
.4
Oct 17 |
►Poelcapelle |
.9
Oct 17 |
►Passchendaele |
.12
Oct 17 |
►Cambrai, 1917 |
20
Nov-3 Dec 17 |
German Offensive: 1918
►Somme, 1918 |
.21
Mar-5 Apr 18 |
►St. Quentin |
.21-23
Mar 18 |
►Bapaume, 1918 |
.24-25
Mar 18 |
►Rosieres |
.26-27
Mar 18 |
►Avre |
.4
Apr 18 |
►Lys |
.9-29
Apr 18 |
►Estaires |
.9-11
Apr 18 |
►Messines, 1918 |
.10-11
Apr 18 |
►Bailleul |
.13-15
Apr 18 |
►Kemmel |
.17-19
Apr 18 |
Advance to Victory: 1918
►Arras, 1918 |
.26
Aug-3 Sep 18 |
►Scarpe, 1918 |
26-30 Aug 18. |
►Drocourt-Queant |
.2-3
Sep 18 |
►Hindenburg Line |
.12
Sep-9 Oct 18 |
►Canal du Nord |
.27
Sep-2 Oct 18 |
►St. Quentin Canal |
.29
Sep-2 Oct 18 |
►Epehy |
3-5
Oct 18 |
►Cambrai, 1918 |
.8-9
Oct 18 |
►Valenciennes |
.1-2
Nov 18 |
►Sambre |
.4
Nov 18 |
►Pursuit to Mons |
.28 Sep-11Nov |
Second World War
War Against Japan
South-East Asia
Italian Campaign
Battle of Sicily
Southern
Italy
The Sangro and Moro
Battles of the FSSF
►Anzio |
22
Jan-22 May 44 |
►Rome |
.22
May-4 Jun 44 |
►Advance
|
.22
May-22 Jun 44 |
to the Tiber |
. |
►Monte Arrestino |
25
May 44 |
►Rocca Massima |
27
May 44 |
►Colle Ferro |
2
Jun 44 |
Cassino
►Cassino II |
11-18
May 44 |
►Gustav Line |
11-18
May 44 |
►Sant' Angelo in
|
13
May 44 |
Teodice |
. |
►Pignataro |
14-15 May 44 |
Liri Valley
►Hitler Line |
18-24 May 44 |
►Melfa Crossing |
24-25 May 44 |
►Torrice Crossroads |
30
May 44 |
Advance to Florence
Gothic Line
►Gothic Line |
25 Aug-22 Sep 44 |
►Monteciccardo |
27-28 Aug 44 |
►Point 204 (Pozzo Alto) |
31 Aug 44 |
►Borgo Santa Maria |
1 Sep 44 |
►Tomba di Pesaro |
1-2 Sep 44 |
Winter Lines
►Rimini Line |
14-21 Sep 44 |
►San Martino- |
14-18 Sep 44 |
San Lorenzo |
. |
►San Fortunato |
18-20 Sep 44 |
►Sant' Angelo |
11-15 Sep 44 |
in Salute |
. |
►Bulgaria Village |
13-14 Sep 44 |
►Pisciatello |
16-19 Sep 44 |
►Savio Bridgehead |
20-23
Sep 44 |
►Monte La Pieve |
13-19
Oct 44 |
►Monte Spaduro |
19-24 Oct 44 |
►Monte San Bartolo |
11-14
Nov 44 |
►Lamone Crossing |
2-13
Dec 44 |
►Capture of Ravenna |
3-4
Dec 44 |
►Naviglio Canal |
12-15 Dec 44 |
►Fosso Vecchio |
16-18 Dec 44 |
►Fosso Munio |
19-21 Dec 44 |
►Conventello- |
2-6 Jan 45 |
Comacchio |
. |
Northwest Europe
Battle of Normandy
►Quesnay Road |
10-11 Aug 44 |
►St. Lambert-sur- |
19-22 Aug 44 |
Southern France
Channel Ports
The Scheldt
Nijmegen Salient
Rhineland
►The
Reichswald |
8-13 Feb 45 |
►Waal
Flats |
8-15 Feb 45 |
►Moyland
Wood |
14-21 Feb 45 |
►Goch-Calcar
Road |
19-21 Feb 45 |
►The
Hochwald |
26
Feb- |
. |
4
Mar 45 |
►Veen |
6-10 Mar 45 |
►Xanten |
8-9
Mar 45 |
Final Phase
►The
Rhine |
23
Mar-1 Apr 45 |
►Emmerich-Hoch
|
28
Mar-1 Apr 45 |
Elten |
. |
Korean War
|
Domestic Missions |
►FLQ
Crisis |
International
Missions |
►ICCS
Vietnam 1973
►MFO
Sinai 1986- |
Peacekeeping |
►UNTEA |
W. N. Guinea 1963-1964 |
►ONUCA |
C. America
1989-1992 |
►UNTAC |
Cambodia
1992-1993 |
►UNMOP |
Prevlaka
1996-2001 |
|
Exercises |
|
Falaise
Falaise
was a Battle Honour granted to units who participated in the actions
to close the Falaise Gap during the Battle
of Normandy, the first phase of the North-West Europe campaign of
the Second World War. Several of these actions were also recognized
by the grant of a separate Battle Honour to the units involved.
Background
The capture of Caen
on 9 July 1944 brought to a close the initial phase of the Battle of
Normandy. General Bernard Montgomery, commanding all Allied land
forces in the bridgehead, turned his attention to the next phase of
operations. In his opinion, further offensive action should include
the destruction of German armour, the capture of Falaise, and the
encirclement and destruction of the German 7th Army by both the U.S.
1st Army and British 2nd Army.1 The offensive operations
at Verrières Ridge proceeded as part of the overall plan to expand
the bridgehead. Operation SPRING on 25 July failed to take the ridge
while the Americans began Operation COBRA on the same day. The U.S.
Army secured St. Lô and began blasting their way out of the hedgerow
country, advancing 40 miles in five days to take Avranches. A
Canadian Army official historical summary noted that the "tremendous
operations which were now beginning are second in importance to none
in the whole history of the war."2 |
|
|
|
The Normandy
bridgehead and front line, as it developed between 16 June 1944
(ten days after D-Day, or D+10) and 24 July 1944.
On 25 July
1944 major offensives opened on both the western (U.S.) and
eastern (British-Canadian) sectors of the bridgehead. |
With American forces
streaming west into Brittany and south past Mayenne and Laval, the
German situation in Normandy became desperate. British forces continued
their attacks to keep pressure on the Germans, attacking toward Vire on
1 August and to the Orne on the 7th.3 General Montgomery's
plan for the battle in Normandy, laid out in April 1944 (before the
landings) envisioned a drawing of German armour to the British front at
Caen while U.S. forces took the Cherbourg peninsula, then wheeled
eastwards. By the end of July the preconditions for the great wheel to
the east seemed to be in place.4
The British breakout
battle began with Operation BLUECOAT on 30 July. The 30th Corps began
the operation with attacks on a three-brigade front, 8th Corps joining
in an hour later while U.S. forces on their flank continued to attack
towards Vire. The operation continued until 4 August and succeeded in
pushing the British line several kilometres to the south.5
Operation TOTALIZE
Success by both the
British and Americans created the opportunity for decisive action by 1st
Canadian Army. By the end of July, the armoured divisions that had
garrisoned the right of the German line at Caen and continued to bar the
way to Falaise began moving away from the British front. By 7 August
1944 only a single panzer division remained opposite the Canadians,
following the transfer of the 1st SS, 2nd, 9th SS, and 21st Panzer
Divisions. While three new infantry divisions entered the line, and with
them formidable anti-tank weapons, "to break through these positions was
now a more practicable operation of war."6 General H.D.G.
Crerar, commanding First Canadian Army, outlined a "basic tactical plan"
that called for surprise. While the Germans would certainly be expecting
an attack on the Canadian front, he hoped to secure surprise by timing
and method of attack.7
See also article on
Falaise Road
Operation TOTALIZE,
launched on 7 August 1944, was planned by 2nd Canadian Corps to achieve
the maximum surprise desired by Crerar. Lieutenant-General Guy Simonds,
commanding the corps, utilized a number of unique tactical innovations
in the initial attack. He planned the breakthrough battle to occur at
night, and mounted the infantry in armoured vehicles, including
halftracks, universal carriers, and for the first time, fully-tracked
armoured personnel carriers, which he created by stripping the armament
from self-propelled guns. Direction finding for the attacking columns
was aided by the use of tracers firing on fixed lines, special
navigation parties, coloured star shells and the use of artificial
moonlight (searchlights bouncing off of low-lying clouds).8
TOTALIZE was a two-phase
attack, with heavy bomber support preceding each phase. The initial,
night, assault was supported by the Royal Air Force and the United
States Army Air Force supported the second, daylight, follow-up attacks.
The Army Commander noted the anniversary; 8 August 1918 had been
described by General Ludendorff as the "black day of the German Army" as
it marked the beginning of the final 100 day offensive that finished the
First World War. There was hope that a similar chain of events might be
set off as the Battle of Normandy drew to a close.
Phase I commenced half an
hour before midnight on 7/8 August. The 51st (Highland) Division and the
2nd Canadian Division attacked in four columns each, each column
consisting of a squadron of tanks in the lead, followed by flail and
AVRE vehicles, a mounted infantry battalion in armoured carriers, and
additional tanks following behind. The columns by-passed strong-points
while infantry on foot mopped up.
The wisdom of
General Simonds' plan of attack was more than vindicated by the
event. The armoured columns tore through the Germans' front
positions, and in the early hours of the morning they were fighting
in the vicinity of their first objectives far to the rear and had
almost cleared them. Thanks to the armoured carriers and the degree
of surprise that had been attained, the infantry had been carried
through the German fire zone and deposited close to these objectives
with very few casualties. Meanwhile, the marching battalions moving
up in rear had entered the villages of the enemy's front line, those
little hamlets with the bloodstained names - May-sur-Orne,
Fontenay-le-Marmion, Roquancourt, Tilly-la-Campagne. By following
close behind the barrages put down by our guns, they got into them
with comparatively little trouble, but some very bitter fighting
followed.9
Phase I had achieved its goal of breaking
through German defences north of Falaise, and did so "after suffering
remarkably few casualties in men and equipment, especially by the bloody
standards of Normandy."10
Phase II was delivered against the next line
of German defences, sitting on high ground five miles further on,
beginning at 13:55hrs on 8 August 1944. The attack was marred by
short-bombing by U.S.A.A.F. heavy bombers, and several casualties were
caused among Canadian and Polish troops, including the tactical
headquarters of 3rd Canadian Infantry Division. Major-General Rod
Keller, the General Officer Commanding the division, was wounded and
evacuated. Brigadier R.A. Wyman, commanding the 2nd Canadian Armoured
Brigade, was also wounded while conducting personal reconnaissance
during the day.
The Polish armour passed
through the 51st (Highland) Division while the 4th (Canadian) Armoured
Division passed through the 2nd Canadian Division, taking the high
ground that flanked the Caen-Falaise road. The Canadian Army's official
historian concluded that "Had the two armoured divisions not been
fighting their first real battle, they might perhaps have got further on
this day. As it was, they did not attain the final objectives and
further advance had to be deferred until the morrow."11
General Simonds
was gambling for high stakes in Operation Totalize. So far,
his gamble was paying off. His night attack had taken the enemy by
surprise and had propelled 60,000 combat troops eight miles deep
into enemy territory in the early hours of 8 August. But the
ill-fated bombing raid later on the same afternoon that was to
initiate the next phase of the attack backfired. It failed to subdue
the Germans and, in fact, caused heavy casualties and confusion
among the unfortunate Allied soldiers caught by "friendly bombs."
The 1st Polish and
4th Canadian Armoured Divisions - fresh to Normandy and totally
unrehearsed in the battle plan - were plunged into exactly the
situation Simonds had tried so hard to prevent. They clashed head-on
in broad daylight, with no support, against a well-entrenched and
heavily armed enemy. That they managed to advance at all was a great
achievement. For one infantry battalion, the Canadian Argylls, it
was a superb effort, ranking in tactical brilliance and raw courage
with the best in any war. For another armoured unit, the British
Columbia Regiment (BCR), it was a gallant effort, but one of the
most disastrous of the war.12
The Germans relocated to
new defensive positions, and the continued assault on 9 August made
little progress. In one notable instance, the 28th Canadian Armoured
Regiment (British Columbia Regiment) became confused and navigated to
the wrong hill. the navigation error was compounded by the inability to
contact supporting artillery, and as the sun rose, the exposed BCR was
blasted apart by superior German firepower. The regiment lost 47 tanks,
various other vehicles, and 240 men including the commanding officer.13
See also article on
Quesnay Wood
Operation TOTALIZE had driven eight miles
toward Falaise, achieving the objective of breaking through the German
front. Falaise itself lay eight miles distant. On the night of 10-11
August 1944, an attack was mounted against Quesnay Wood by the 8th
Canadian Brigade in order to push German units back from the
Caen-Falaise road, but this assault was driven back with heavy
casualties. "It was apparent that it would be necessary to mount another
deliberate attack with powerful support to break through the new enemy
gun-screen."14
Counter-attack at
Mortain
As the Canadians
attempted to advance their front and emulate the successes of the
Americans and British to their right, the Germans engaged in offensive
operations of their own. In an effort to cut the communication and
supply lines of the U.S. 3rd Army that was advancing south and west past
Avranches, Hitler personally directed that a German armoured
counter-attack be mounted west across the Cotentin peninsula, beginning
east of Mortain and aimed at Avranches.15
The attack was the most
powerful yet attempted by the Germans in the west, commencing on 6
August with five panzer divisions on a front between Mortain and Vire.
The attack saw little success, yet the Germans "continued to pour in
(their) forces recklessly in spite of very heavy losses."16
As the Germans continued to deploy their mobile forces in
the west against the Americans, the prospect of taking Falaise, and of
cutting off the bulk of the German armies in France, became more likely.
See also article on
Clair Tison
As the main follow up operation to
TOTALIZE was planned, the 2nd Canadian Division engaged in subsidiary
operations on the right flank of 1st Canadian Army aimed at clearing out
the wooded areas west of the River Laize and linking up with the British
2nd Army, which was advancing across the Orne River.17
The Germans were already
pulling back from their failed Mortain counter-offensive, beginning on
12 August. A gap was created between Falaise and Argentan through which
retreating elements of the enemy armies were beginning to move, and five
different national forces were moving to close the gap.
Patton's XV Corps
with the 2nd French Armoured was nearing Argentan, fifteen miles
south of Falaise; the British were squeezing the retreating enemy
units from behind, forcing them more and more tightly into the
narrow escape hatch. On the ridge overlooking the Laison River, the
Canadians and Poles were exerting pressure from the north and
north-east. They were eight miles from Falaise.
A mere twenty-five
miles separated the two jaws of the trap.18
On the same day,
two brigades of the 2nd Canadian Infantry Division were ordered to mount
a reconnaissance in force toward the town of Clair Tizon, with
intermediate objectives of Barbery and Moulines. The Royal Hamilton
Light Infantry's attack on Barbery was designated the main effort for
the entire 2nd Canadian Corps, and at a cost of 20 dead and 100 wounded
seized Barbery.
The 4th Brigade passed
through to take Moulines in hand-to-hand fighting. After midnight on 13
August 1944, the Calgary Highlanders continued on to the final objective
at Clair Tizon, taking the vital bridge over the Laize in a daring
night-time action, passing through enemy lines. Le Régiment de
Maisonneuve finished the attack with an under-strength company.
In darkness, fresh
troops from the 6th Brigade waded across the river and secured the
high ground. Falaise was now barely six miles south-west of them.
The end was in sight. Second Canadian Division was well south of any
other Canadian or British unit.19
Sherman tanks of The Fort Garry Horse
near Brettevile-le-Rabet, France on 14 August 1944. LAC photo.
Operation TRACTABLE
See also article on
The Laison
The final effort to break through to Falaise
bore great similarities to Operation TOTALIZE. Named TRACTABLE, the
operation was conducted in two phases and utilized great columns of
armour and mounted infantry. Instead of using the cover of darkness,
front and flanks of the attack were screened by smoke. Two columns were
used in the first phase, each column with two infantry brigades and an
armoured brigade. The formations involved were the 3rd Canadian Infantry
Division, 4th Canadian (Armoured) Division and 2nd Canadian Armoured
Brigade. To maintain surprise, there was no preliminary bombardment.
Fighter bombers attacked for 20 minutes before H-Hour, and the units
crossed the start line at noon on 14 August 1944 as artillery laid great
quantities of smoke across the front and flanks.
The attack was
successful, but costly. Many tanks were lost and the commander of the 4th Armoured
Brigade was killed. A copy of the operation order found its way into
German hands in the confusion of the battle, allowing the Germans to
deploy anti-tank weapons to vulnerable positions. The second phase of the
operation was marred by another short-bombing incident, this time by
R.A.F. planes, who nonetheless provided material support to the attack
despite the error. By the evening of 14 August, Canadian troops were on
the heights above Falaise and by the morning of the 15th the 2nd and 3rd
Canadian Divisions were being directed to complete the capture of the
town itself.20
The command to take Falaise actually represented a change in plans, as
British divisions had been closer to Falaise, but were blocked by
stubborn German resistance.
It was certainly a
good command decision by Montgomery and illustrated his hands-on
grip of the action, although critics might carp that he should have
planned it that way at the outset and allocated to Crerar the
resources necessary to do the job. Be that as it may, the problem
was now in Crerar's hands and the Canadians would have to adjust in
mid-battle. They would also have to do it with the formations that
they had. Simonds, the Corps Commander responsible, decided to use
the 3rd Infantry and 4th Armoured Divisions in the original
left-hook role north-east of Falaise while 2nd Infantry Division was
assigned the difficult job of taking that city - the birthplace of
William the Conqueror.21
The 2nd Division entered
the town on the 16th, the same day that Point 159, the heights above the
town, fell. By noon on 17 August Falaise was cleared, the last
strongpoints around a monastery holding out until midnight. Entire
streets had been reduced to rubble.22
Sherman tank of the 27th
Canadian Armoured Regiment (The Sherbrooke Fusilier
Regiment) with infantry of Les Fusiliers Mont-Royal in
Falaise on 17 August 1944. LAC photo.
Pte. A. B. Lockhart and Pte. W. H. Campbell amidst the wreckage of
Falaise in August 1944.
Lockhart wears despatch riders breeches and boots while Campbell has
what appears to be a French medal on his shirt and a captured
German holster on his belt. His scarf is a standard issue camouflaged
face veil. LAC Photo
See also article on
Chambois
As the 1st Canadian Army drove south, the
other Allied armies in Normandy were continuing their own operations.
The U.S. 1st Army drove forward at the Germans attacking toward Mortain,
pushing them back and establishing contact with the British 2nd Army.
The U.S. 3rd Army continued a rapid drive to the east, through Le Mans,
and then looping north again towards the rear of the German divisions
facing the Canadians. By 13 August Patton's lead forces were approaching
Argentan, about fifteen miles south-east of Falaise.
The result was
that the enemy's forces were now in a "pocket" threatened by
complete encirclement as the Canadian jaw of the pincers cut south
through Falaise and the American jaw moved northward from the
vicinity of Argentan. Realizing, somewhat belatedly, the extreme
danger to which he was exposed, the enemy pulled back a major part
of his armour to hold the American advance, and its northward
progress was greatly slowed, though to the east it continued
unchecked. The burning question now was whether the Germans could
withdraw their forces, or important parts of them, before the jaws
of the trap closed. Eastward movement out of the area had certainly
been in progress for some days, but vast numbers of Germans remained
in jeopardy.23
|
On 13 August 1944, a day before
TRACTABLE and the final effort to push to Falaise, the Germans
had abandoned their failed Mortain offensive. As TRACTABLE
closed four days later, the Allies were
driving hard to close the "Falaise Gap" - encircling the German
forces in Normandy in an effort to destroy them. |
The 4th Canadian (Armoured) Division
occupied Turn on the night of 17-18 August, as well as the high ground
to the north, cutting one of the few good roads the Germans had
available to effect their withdrawal from the pocket. The 4th Armoured
were relieved by the 3rd Canadian Infantry Division, and General
Montgomery directed the 1st Polish Armoured Division on Chambois,
south-east of Trun. They carried on over broken ground despite German
resistance from inside and outside the pocket. By the 18th, American
troops were two miles from Chambois in the Forest of Gouffern, while the
Poles were themselves within striking distance.
The Germans, desperate to
escape, had no choice but to resort to mass road movement by daylight
despite Allied air superiority. As the gap through which they could
safely retreat shrank, targets of opportunity for the air forces grew.
Artillery fire was concentrated on the German escape routes. Hundreds of
men and vehicles fell victim to fire, but desperate fighting continued
around Trun and Chambois. On the evening of 19 August, the Poles finally
made contact with the U.S. 90th Infantry Division, technically closing
the Falaise Gap, but "the condition remained critical for some time
thereafter; it could not be asserted that there was a continuous
established line containing the enemy, and at times the situation at
various points was far from clear."24 The Poles were in fact
cut off from the rest of 1st Canadian Army for a time, and on 21 August
an air-lift of ammunition had to be provided to them. They nicknamed
their position on Hill 262 Maczuga (the Mace) and held out with
the assistance of the Canadian Army Group Royal Artillery (AGRA).25
During this period
of extraordinarily savage and chaotic fighting, there were certainly
many fierce encounters of which no full account was ever put on
paper. But some incidents of those desperate days have been clearly
recorded and serve to give us some idea of what was passing in the
whole area about the Gap. We know, for instance, that on 20 August
two squadrons of the 18th Canadian Armoured Car Regiment (12th
Manitoba Dragoons), forsaking their normal role of reconnaissance,
devoted themselves to working havoc among the struggling enemy, and
continued to do so until their ammunition was exhausted, killing
hundreds and capturing "well over a thousand".26
See also article on
St. Lambert-sur-Dives
One of the "fierce encounters" of note was
at St. Lambert-sur-Dives. The South Alberta Regiment was the armoured
reconnaissance regiment of the 4th Armoured Division, though in practice
the regiment was equipped with Sherman tanks identically to the three
armoured regiments of the division and often performed tasks other than
reconnaissance. Their "C" Squadron under Major David Currie, with a
company of The Argyll and Sutherland Highlanders of Canada, advanced on
St. Lambert. German fire knocked out several tanks and desperate Germans
continued to pour through the gap. Currie and his battle group continued
on and on the morning of 19 August had captured most of St. Lambert,
knocking out two tanks. At 11:00hrs a German convoy was brought under
fire and destroyed. The rest of the SAR moved up into supporting
positions and artillery observers and the air forces joined in the
fighting. German shell and mortar fire intensified cutting off "B"
Squadron, but at 18:00hrs Currie's force was reinforced inside St.
Lambert. German attacks intensified. By dusk on the 20th, seven enemy
tanks, twelve 88mm guns, and forty trucks had been destroyed, 300 enemy
soldiers killed, 500 wounded and over 2,000 captured. All of Currie's
officers had been killed or wounded in the course of three days
fighting, but St. Lambert was finally taken. Currie received the
Victoria Cross, the first of the campaign in Northwest Europe and the
only one approved for a soldier of the Royal Canadian Armoured Corps.27
One of the most well-known
Canadian images of the Second World War. Major David V. Currie,
third from left with pistol in hand, oversees a German surrender
during the fighting at St. Lambert on 19 August 1944. Currie
commanded a battle group made up of tanks from his own 29th
Armoured Reconnaissance Regiment (The South Alberta Regiment)
and infantry of The Argyll and Sutherland Highlanders of Canada
(Princess Louise's). It is often said that this photo is the
nearest that war photographers of the Second World War came to
capturing a man in the act of earning the Victoria Cross. Currie
was the only soldier of the Royal Canadian Armoured Corps to be
awarded the VC. LAC Photo
The End
On 20 August, the 4th
Armoured Brigade was belatedly moved south, aiding the Poles on Maczuga
and at last sealing the Gap by moving into positions behind the
Trun-Chambois road.
Why (Major-General
Kitching) had not ordered this last mission two days before is a
mystery and one which probably contributed to his later sacking.
Partly due to this tardiness the Germans would later claim that up
to 40% of their troops who were still in the pocket on the 20th
managed to make their escape. But thousands did not.28
Canadian tanks reached
the Poles on the afternoon of the 21st. The Falaise Gap was truly closed
at last. The German 7th Army had been shattered, and so many of their
soldiers had been killed in the Falaise Gap that bodies lay unburied for
weeks. Total casualties for Canadian troops from 7 August to 23 August
(from the start of TOTALIZE to the end of the fighting to seal the
Falaise Gap) were 389 officers and 5,795 other ranks killed, died of
wounds, wounded and missing. Prisoners taken on the front of 1st
Canadian Army totalled 18,381. There was no attempt to tabulate the
number of German dead.29
The Canadian official
historian noted that a "(i)t had been a great victory."30
Other historians later criticized the way in which the victory had been
won:
Of course, it was
not (the last great battle of the war): and to make it such would
have required an adventurousness and flexibility quite alien to most
Allied armies. Among the Canadians, generally speaking, the fault
lay not with the regimental soldier or his officers, but in the
slow, deliberate British doctrine, founded in First World War
experience, to which commanders rigidly adhered. They had long
over-emphasized firepower at the expense of manoeuvre, and
under-emphasized the coordination of the three combat arms -
infantry, armour and artillery - which was...the essence of mobile
warfare...
Tactical and
operational weaknesses were compounded at the strategic level, where
Montgomery still controlled the ground battle. Arbitrary boundaries,
inflexible procedures, and monumental egos (of Bradley and Patton,
as well as Montgomery) excused - or prevented - the Americans from
pressing north to meet Crerar's men and close the pocket. Tens of
thousands of Germans fled eastward, out of its slowly narrowing
mouth, ravaged and decimated as they went by the awesome power of
tactical air forces.31
John English was even more strident in his
criticism:
The operational,
strategic and operational consequences of a Canadian triumph in
Normandy are impossible to know. Had the First Canadian Army
succeeded in its 8 August drive to Falaise (webmaster's note:
Operation TOTALIZE)...it is not unreasonable to presume that it
might have, as in 1918, spearheaded the British Army's advance into
the heartland of Europe. The tragedy was that on the morning of the
26th anniversary of the Battle of Amiens, Simonds's corps had
cleanly sliced open the German defensive zone without realizing
it...
In very large
measure, responsibility for the relatively lacklustre showing of
Canadian arms in Normandy must be laid at the feet of division
commanders....At best, Simonds's immediate subordinates were
mediocre performers. Even at brigade level, with the possible
exception of Foster, a lack of tactical judgement was often evident.32
More recent research by
Brian Reid is slightly more forgiving, particularly with regards to
TOTALIZE, and writes:
...TOTALIZE was
successful, although it could and should have achieved more, more
quickly. That it ultimately floundered on indecision and hesitation
was due as much to cumbersome doctrine, inferior equipment and an
unwieldy plan as it was to a few flawed commanders and the inability
of the Allied air forces to follow through on their claims. However,
it is indicative of the conditions under which the Allied armies
fought in Normandy, that no one at the time thought that it was
other than a successful operation of war.33
Battle Honours
The following units were
awarded the Battle Honour "Falaise":
II Canadian Corps
2nd Canadian Armoured Brigade
-
6th Canadian Armoured Regiment (1st Hussars)
-
10th Canadian Armoured Regiment (The Fort Garry Horse)
-
27th Canadian Armoured Regiment (The Sherbrooke Fusilier
Regiment)
2nd Canadian Division
4th Canadian Infantry Brigade
-
The Royal Regiment of Canada
-
The Royal Hamilton Light Infantry
-
The Essex Scottish Regiment
5th Canadian Infantry Brigade
6th Canadian Infantry Brigade
3rd Canadian Division
7th Canadian Infantry Brigade
-
The Royal Winnipeg Rifles
-
The Regina Rifle Regiment
-
The Canadian Scottish Regiment
8th Canadian Infantry Brigade
-
The Queen's Own Rifles of Canada
-
Le Régiment de la Chaudière
-
The North Shore (New Brunswick) Regiment
9th Canadian Infantry Brigade
-
The Highland Light Infantry of Canada
-
The Stormont, Dundas and Glengarry Highlanders
-
The North Nova Scotia Highlanders
4th Canadian (Armoured) Division
4th Canadian Armoured Brigade
-
21st Armoured Regiment (The Governor General's Foot Guards)
-
22nd Armoured Regiment (The Grenadier Guards)
-
28th Armoured Regiment (The British Columbia Regiment)
10th Canadian Infantry Brigade
Notes
-
McKay, A. Donald Gaudeamus Igitur
"Therefore Rejoice" (Bunker to Bunker Books,
Calgary, AB, 2005) ISBN 1894255534 p.151
-
Stacey, C.P. Canada's Battle in Normandy: The
Canadian Army's Share in the Operations 6 June - 1 September 1944
(King's Printer, Ottawa, ON, 1946) p.103
-
Ibid, p. 105
-
Ellis, L.F. Victory in the West: Volume I The
Battle of Normandy (Queen's Printer, 1962 - reprint by The
Naval and Military Press Ltd, Uckfield, East Sussex, UK, 2004) ISBN
1-845740-58-0 p.405
-
Ford, Ken Falaise: Death of an Army
(Osprey Publishing Ltd, Botley, Oxford, UK, 2005) ISBN
978-1-84176-626-3 pp.37-39
-
Stacey, Ibid, pp.106-107
-
Ibid, p.107
-
McKay, Ibid, pp.165-166
-
Stacey, Ibid, pp.113-114
-
Reid, Brian. No Holding Back:
Operation Totalize, Normandy, August 1944. (Robin Brass
Studio, Toronto, ON, 2005) ISBN 1-896941-40-0 pp.359-360
-
Stacey, Ibid, pp.114-115
-
Whitaker, Denis and Shelagh Whitaker (with Terry Copp)
Victory at Falaise: The Soldier's Story (HarperCollins
Publishers Ltd., Toronto, ON, 2000) ISBN 0-00-200017-2
p.123
-
Bechtold, Mike "Lost in Normandy: The Odyssey of
Worthington Force 9 August 1944" Canadian Military History,
Volume 19, Number 2, Spring 2010
-
Stacey, Ibid, p.117
-
Edwards, Roger Panzer: A Revolution in Warfare,
1939-1945 (Brockhampton Press, UK, 1998) ISBN 1-86019-8538
p.222
-
Stacey, Ibid, p.117
-
Ibid, p.118
-
Whitaker, Ibid, pp.149
-
Ibid, p..149-158
-
Stacey, Ibid, pp.119-121
-
McKay, Ibid, p.174
-
Stacey, Ibid, p.121
-
Ibid, pp.121-122
-
Ibid, pp.123-126
-
McKay, Ibid, p.179
-
Stacey, Ibid, pp.126-127
-
McKay, Ibid, pp.178-179
-
Ibid, p.179
-
Stacey, Ibid, p.133
-
Ibid, p.133
-
Greenhous, Brereton "The
Victory Campaign 1944-45" We Stand on Guard: An Illustrated
History of the Canadian Army (Ovale Publications, Montreal,
PQ, 1992) ISBN 2894290438 p.304
-
English, John A. The Canadian Army and the
Normandy Campaign (Stackpole Books, Mechanicsburg, PA, 2009)
ISBN 978-0-8117-3576-6 pp.238-239
-
Reid, Ibid, p.366
|